Affordable: Slums of Mumbai - Exterior
Alley
In formal urban fabric, an alley is used strictly for circulation or utilities. In slum fabric, they serve multiple additional functions that bring them closer to the program of an urban street.
Wide. At their widest, alleys are around ten feet. Traffic access (and therefore its transition to a street) is blocked by other functions: wet corners, porches, stand-alone shrines, etc. In the air, extensive balconies further obstruct the alley, which also hosts wet-corner and porch programs for the units above. Laundry lines cross the alley from balcony to balcony. Some balconies extend far enough to touch their counterparts across the alley, although this is generally avoided. There is enough space for the stairs to be perpendicular to the alley and outside the balcony footprint, giving the unit above more balcony space and the units below more façade. A water/sewer line runs through the middle of the alley, preventing any items or structures from being placed on top of it. The free space above the water/sewer line becomes a natural choice for pedestrian circulation. Water/sewer line thus serves two functions - an impressive level of utilization, which is a typical condition repeated across all alleys. Together, all elements create a vibrant, enjoyable environment, especially for kids playing active mobility games throughout.
Medium. As the alley shrinks, the stairs turn parallel to it and enter the balcony footprint. The only way for the stairs to remain perpendicular to the alley is to enter the building footprint, with some residents electing to do so. Wet corner and porch programs remain on and below the balconies, on both sides of the alley. Clothing lines also turn parallel to the alley, as there is not enough space to stretch them across. Balconies enclosing the alley happen more often. However, some residents recess the second floor (or lack the means to maximize the footprint) and claim sunlight, allowing programs such as potted plants or commercial and manufacturing activity. The neighbor quickly adds a side window and shares the sunlight without compromising the floor plan. As before, a water/sewer line anchors the circulation. Kids make do with less room to play, limiting their game mobility and setting up a board game on the ship ladder steps, standing both in front of and under it.
Narrow. As the squeeze continues, more program elements enter interior spaces. The buildings absorb the stairs, as there is no longer space for them outside. The wet corner becomes internalized, leaving only occasional water containers on the porch. Porch functions flatten themselves against the walls and become shelves. Balconies fall out of favor, i.e., turn into jettyings and interiors. With balconies and exterior spaces gone, play areas are reduced to just circulation over the water/sewer line. However, the children take advantage by playing cricket, since there is little space for a ball to get lost.
Ultra-narrow. The second floor on both sides meet in the middle, creating an enclosed corridor roughly the width of the water/sewer line. Any nook and cranny the water/sewer line leaves unclaimed is used for storage. Sometimes the sewer opens up to gain more space, even allowing a daring, squished exterior stair. Other ways to gain space include creating a small cubby by stepping a wall, which comes at the cost of reduced interior space. Thus, a tense stand-off exists between interior and exterior spaces. Light enters the alley through side corridors on the first and second floors. Occasional light wells are claimed by commercial activity and used as natural advertisements. Clothing hangs over the doors, as there is nowhere else to put it. Enclosed alleys are dramatic, yet not very enjoyable spaces to inhabit. The kids disperse to play in less constricted alleys.
Commercial. Alleys dominated by businesses are uncommon, as businesses generally require robust transportation access. Commercial alleys prioritize revenue over all other programs. Access to light is limited as the alley is framed by structures up to six stories tall. Most businesses are B to B and not customer-facing, manufacturing a variety of goods, such as clothing and bags. All these factors combined create an unwelcoming, dirty, neglected environment. Windows facing a commercial alley are tiny. Leftover bay windows are filled with trash and discarded items. Few people choose to live or do customer-facing business here, and if they do, they create a small island of cleanliness right at their door.
Street
B to B (recycling). 13th compound, a recycling community, has the widest streets and the largest structures in Dharavi, enabling it to process 80% of Mumbai's plastic and dry waste. The facades are rag-tag and featureless, as most buildings are warehouses with small processing areas. Infrequent residential structures are deeper in the alleys. Retail is limited. Dealing with recycling waste every day, the street creates an oxymoronic impression: spacious and bright, yet dirty and unwelcoming.
B to C. The commercial street is wide to support deliveries to businesses. Additionally, the width creates a welcoming environment for customers and allows prominent ad display. Driven by a steady stream of money, the structures here are higher quality, with flashy finishes that compete for customers’ attention. Streets are crammed with transport and people, all in one stream. Commercial activity happens on the ground floor, with other floors reserved for residential spaces. The businesses take over the sidewalk, creating waiting areas or displaying merchandise. If they don't, traveling merchants will claim the sidewalk directly in front of them instead (no space in the slums can be functionless). Traveling merchants are there illegally, don't pay taxes to the government, and are therefore a target of police raids. However, they are there with permission from a local business (some benefit from the foot traffic traveling merchants generate) and pay "taxes" to a local community organization that guarantees their spot. Therefore, one can't just park their papaya cart wherever they please.
Residential. A luxury in the slum, residential streets are rare. Residents of such streets were among the community's founders and were lucky to claim as much livable space as they wanted. Later waves of settlers were crammed into increasingly small alleys. Having lived here the longest, many residents found jobs in the formal economy. Transportation access focuses less on bringing goods in and more on getting people to their jobs across Mumbai. Residents’ transport, ranging from bicycles to e-bikes, mopeds, and full-sized cars, is parked directly in front of their dwellings. The scale of full-sized cars makes for an intimidating presence in the slum fabric, taking a footprint larger than some dwellings. Properties here are robust, tidy, sometimes fully formalized, and command a steep price, reaching $150,000 or more. This price repels all but the wealthiest developers, who must build residential skyscrapers to recoup their land-acquisition losses. Most of such communities are therefore left alone.
Fun fact. Slums have a reputation for being dirty because most tours happen in slum streets and commercial areas, where cleanliness is far from a top priority. Residential areas, which make up most slums, are clean, but tourists rarely venture there.
Plaza
An open space of any kind is under constant programmatic pressure to be better utilized - filled with structures. As a result, many plazas became significantly smaller or vanished due to infill. A plaza can survive only if it has a well-defined function.
POTTERY PLAZA
Pottery production is a powerful plaza-forming program. Even so, pottery plazas shrank over the years because of infills and manufacturing changes.
Kiln. A multi-functional kiln is the defining feature of a pottery plaza and the main feature that preserves it. Kilns are used to fire a variety of clay pots, store them, and air-dry them before firing. Any available waste and recycling material is used for firing, filling the plaza with noxious smoke, leaving soot deposits on surrounding buildings, and disrupting their program. Some kilns are now pushed onto rooftops, further putting pottery plazas at risk of extinction. Temporary structures and roofs are erected above the kilns to maximize space for air drying and protect the kiln from rain. Kilns can be fully disassembled as needed for an event (such as a wedding) and reassembled afterward.
Manufacturing areas. Plazas are utilized for mixing clay, wheel throwing, painting, and decorating the final product. However, many of these functions have moved indoors while maintaining a direct connection to the plaza.
Storage. Copious storage is necessary in any production line. Plazas store products at every production stage, from raw clay and materials for temporary structures to the final product ready to move to stores.
Residences. Some residences face the plaza and often double as workshops.
Buildings. Buildings facing the kiln reduced their windows to the minimum to protect themselves from smoke and soot. Clothing lines appear only when the kiln is not in use. Roofs are actively utilized for air-drying pottery; some even build patios with additional drying racks on the roofs. One building I visited stacked the plaza program into a skyscraper, from mixing clay on the bottom to firing kilns on the top. Others enclose isolated functions, such as wheel-throwing, in a tiny, booth-like container.
Economy. Primarily local, as most pots are bought by Dharavi residents.
LAUNDRY PLAZA
Like the pottery plaza, laundry plazas are under pressure from infills and modernized laundry facilities.
Wash Pens. Dhobi Ghat, a laundry community, existed for over a century and initially started as a laundry facility for the British. Concrete wash pens were built then and are still used today to manually wash clothing by beating it against a flogging stone. The wash-pen basins are lined up in double rows along the central water supply basin and occupy most of the plaza. Wash pens have been altered and modernized over the years. The central basin now hosts plumbing encased in concrete and doubles as an extra circulation core and a landing for ship ladders of the upper floors. The smaller basins often have water pumps. Industrial laundry machines, spin driers, folding and ironing tables, and occasional ship ladders and structural columns for the spaces above intrude on the wash pens.
Clothing lines. Spin driers remove most of the moisture, but they don’t replace clothing lines. Clothing lines dominate the roofs and patios and also stretch across the wash pens. If the lines are too long, the residents prop them up with temporary, unsecured bamboo poles. The clothing lines are two ropes intertwined in a helix pattern, letting them hold clothing without clothespins. Residents sort clothing lines by type and color, creating an impromptu, vibrant art installation.
Residences. The units are paired with wash pens and are the same width, making them among the smallest in all Mumbai slums. Over the years, residents built up the upper floor, creating more residential space, with some upper floors cantilevering over the basins and partially or fully shading them. Nearly all units have corrugated metal roofs, which allow them to host clothing lines. Today, most units are rental, so the decorations are limited.
Machinery. Industrial laundry machinery is gaining popularity in the community and taking more and more space over the years. Most of the machinery is positioned between the residences and the wash pens, if space permits. If it doesn't, the machines can encroach onto wash pens, sometimes taking them out of use. The higher efficiency of industrial laundry machines could be the main driver of the community's vertical growth.
Structure. In addition to the typical steel structure with infills found elsewhere in slums, Dhobi Ghat employs a lightweight metal tube structure to build a trellis for clothing lines. Large tarps shield the whole plaza or individual clothing lines from the elements, as needed.
Economy. Mostly export. Nearby formal hotels, hospitals, and other businesses use the laundry services Dhobi Ghat provides.
COMMUNITY PLAZA
Community plazas are reserved as communal spaces for the adjacent units and exist by consensus among the residents of these units. Canopies often protect these plazas from the elements. The program of community plazas includes shrines, spaces for community organizations, retail, storage, moped parking (you'd have to walk the moped here), etc. Open spaces for community plazas form when various slum clusters meet in awkward, suboptimal ways, making the space not worth developing. Community plazas come in a wide variety of scales, from tiny ones that serve as meeting spaces for only two units to large ones that act as a community nexus.
Edge
Edges form whenever a slum meets urban fabric. Edges present opportunities, but also dangers to the community. Opportunities come from integrating into the urban fabric by providing services or products and establishing a solid revenue source. The danger comes from the urban fabric's natural hostility to informality. The nature of edges, the nature of interaction between the slum and urban fabric, is the key factor in the community's survival.
Factors influencing the edges are:
Passer-bys. If an edge provides a steady stream of passers-by, especially from the formal economy, commerce is inevitable. Those edges are most prized. Commerce benefits slums and the urban fabric alike. It lets the slum show its utility to the urban fabric, creating a symbiotic relationship and soothing its aggression. Being customer-facing, commerce has the nicest finishes and the best buildings in the slums, with facades and structures evolving into full-on urban fabric controlled by the slums - the perfect insulating layer. This allows a slum to hide in plain sight. Formal businesses even end up crossing over and setting up shop in the slums: after all, these are cheap and fairly well-built commercial spaces.
Hardness. A hard edge is a fence, a shore, something a slum can't cross, so it hits the edge and stops abruptly. A soft edge occurs near underutilized pockets of urban fabric, such as parking spaces along the highways. Slums expand into soft edges, test the boundaries, and temporarily retreat if necessary. The trick is not to challenge the soft edge too aggressively, or it will quickly harden by putting up an additional fence.
Hostility. Urban fabric is always hostile to slums to some degree. If the hostility is low, the slums use the edge positively, saturating it with activities, often commerce. If hostility is high, slums use that edge for waste disposal. This isn't malice; it is simply the best use for such an edge: the urban fabric doesn’t want them there, and the place they don’t want to be is among heaps of garbage, so a landfill program naturally aligns two parties. No space in slums will go unused.
Types of Edges
1) TRANSPORTATION ARTERIES AND UTILITY LINES
Road Edge. A slum facing a road has a huge opportunity for commerce.
A formal road provides easy formal supply lines, including full-sized trucks.
A formal road brings massive through-traffic of customers from outside slums with deeper pockets, encouraging a high-margin export economy (from slums to urban fabric).
Roads are wide (even a double-lane road is wider than a residential block in the slums), allowing plenty of natural light, improving customer experience, and making ads larger and more visible. Natural light also permits extensive vegetation, such as full-size trees.
Roads are naturally soft edges. Parking lanes and sidewalks, if there are any, will be taken over by nomad merchants, some selling items straight from the back of their parked vehicles. Low-traffic periods could be exploited to claim portions of lanes (or even full lanes) and set up shops there. It is a balancing act, as you don't want to halt traffic, which would halt commerce, or become too much of a nuisance to drivers, which would draw the ire of authorities. With sidewalks occupied, pedestrian traffic is pushed into the already narrowed lanes, slowing car traffic and putting drivers on high alert. Instead of relaxing and scrolling TikTok while driving, drivers sweat bullets trying not to hit anyone. Thus, Road Edge spontaneously evolved a European walkable-neighborhood doctrine and made the road safer for everyone involved, pedestrians mixed with cars notwithstanding. Also, slow traffic lets passing drivers spot businesses better: they could go from complaining about traffic one minute to buying cheap papayas the next.
Pedestrian Bridge Edge. Pedestrian traffic from Dharavi train station cuts across two highways and is so thick that it used to halt both highways for ninety minutes twice a day during rush hours. To solve this, a long pedestrian bridge was built to lift pedestrian traffic above the highways, leaving the road below as a distinct edge.
Pedestrian bridge traffic is inconsequential because it is entirely detached from the street.
The road below is a slum street, dominated by pedestrian and mixed moped traffic. The width, enforced by the pedestrian bridge above, is abnormally generous for a slum street, almost double the norm. The massive columns of the pedestrian bridge are used as ad spaces. Occasional planters with spiked fences - traffic dividers with unclear purpose - are dully ignored and navigated around. The structures grow tall enough to stop inches from the pedestrian bridge underbelly, but they dare not use it for structural support.
With little non-slum traffic coming through, most businesses are a part of the domestic slum economy: barbers, diners, smoke shops, etc. It makes you wonder whether the street had a booming economy before the bridge and entered decline after it was finished.
Train Track Edge. The edge of the train tracks is harshly and quickly enforced. Trains do not tolerate disruptions, and authorities aren’t shy about security structures and bulldozers. This creates a cautious, tense, conflict-ridden edge. Like any hostile edge in the slum, it becomes a dumping ground for the slum's programmatic issues. In the early days, people used train tracks as bathrooms, to the great displeasure of authorities and train riders. With the deployment of public bathrooms in the slums, the situation greatly improved. Today, train tracks often serve as landfills, which also advertise waste-removal issues for authorities.
Passive train track edge. The most common arrangement. Some put shanties up against the edge, minimize windows, dump trash there, and pretend the edge doesn't exist. Some engage it more, utilizing ample sunlight to grow potted plants. Some go as far as putting a half-alley up against the edge and cautiously using it for views and activities such as laundry and recreation. In this arrangement, residents stay away from the exclusion zone and don't use it as a landfill. They even clean the tracks of the trash thrown out of the trains. This arrangement should be formalized, as it appears to be the most mutually beneficial for both parties. However, if activity becomes disruptive, authorities will quickly put up a fence, creating a hostile edge with all its issues. It is a balancing act that requires patience on both sides. The lesson of the edge: don't expect everyone to use the same asset the same way.
Active train track edge. On a rare occasion, a slum can take over a train track. It can happen on a slow-moving portion of the train track, such as near train stations. Trains still pass through the tracks, but at minimal speed and with more caution than residents walking across it. Such an edge has commercial activity, though tepid, since there is no way to engage with train traffic and few people from the train station will cross the tracks to buy something. Commercial areas are always dirtier than residential, so the track can become littered with waste. This arrangement negatively impacts both parties.
Planned Grid Edge. One approach to slums in India is to give them a grid and forget about them. This harnesses programmatic power and freedom while making slums safer, more efficient, and more uniform. Slum fabric grown within the grid evolves into urban fabric over time. Formal infills are easier, so architects can introduce good architectural practices and ideas into these communities as they would in the urban fabric. Supplying construction materials within the grid is easier, which speeds construction. A grid-based slum fabric is more aesthetically pleasing at ground level and from above, making the surrounding urban fabric less hostile. Overall, providing a designated space and a grid for a slum is the most cost-effective way to create new affordable housing while eliminating many of the negatives of slums. Unfortunately, the grid can't be deployed in the existing clustered slum without tearing it down first.
Stair Edge. The urban fabric needed pedestrian access through a slum to the top of the hill, where a water treatment plant was located. The resulting collaboration of the stair and the slum is surprisingly wholesome.
Improving circulation and access. It lets residents access their dwellings by building makeshift access stairs right on the steps. It extends side stairs to access slum streets and alleys, and streets and alleys can connect to it via their own informal stairs. Some landings seamlessly transition to streets and alleys.
Positive influence of urban fabric. The urban fabric uses the stairs to extend its influence by branching out with formal assets, such as public bathrooms. Formal retaining walls stabilize the hill and make the slum on it safer. The stairs' connections to the slum fabric allow them to serve as community recreation and gathering spaces and provide easy access to the urban fabric at the ends of the stairs.
Water utilities.
Water main. The water main is entombed in concrete and goes underground. The area above and next to it is a large, strictly enforced exclusion zone, cleared through slum demolition and secured with a concrete fence topped with barbed wire. As any hostile edge, it is used for dumping trash and human waste. The fence prevents residents from using the area as a bathroom, so they run sewer lines above it and yeet their garbage over like Olympic hammer throwers. The nearby recycling community somewhat mitigates the situation by using the area as staging grounds for their recycling operations. Some folks from the recycling community also traverse the exclusion zone collecting valuable recycling materials. With human neglect and fertilizer, wild vegetation is actively reclaiming the area. The facades facing the exclusion zone are blank corrugated metal manufacturing facilities with little to no windows. Some residences face the area, but the facades are stripped of all aesthetics.
Water branch. It is impractical to have an exclusion zone above and near water distribution lines, so the residents are permitted to occupy it, but not build anything on top of it. This creates a slum plaza maintained by the water system. The area buzzes with quiet residential activity: kids playing, adults lounging, and chores being done. The area is impeccably clean, as in any other residential area in the slums. There is plenty of space for seasonal festivals and weddings, so the area is often lushly decorated. The area also becomes a natural choice for urban fabric agents such as public bathrooms, community organizations, temples, shrines, etc.
Water distribution. We’ve already mentioned minor water lines running through alleys, but I don’t consider these conditions edges, as slum residents own them and constantly reconfigure them.
***
Lesson learned. The slum will use the area one way or another. If you forbid all positive engagements, such as recreation, you will promote negative engagements, such as a landfill. Good faith engagement always produces better results than bulldozers.
2) NATURE
Slums naturally gravitate toward brownfields, forgotten and underused areas, landfills, swamps, wetlands, and other zones the formal urban fabric has passed over. Therefore, slums run into and reckon with natural barriers such as hills and river banks, engaging them in a variety of ways.
River. Rivers and creeks near the slums have no chance of being anything nice. With overpopulation and persistent waste-management issues, sewage ends up in the water one way or another. The slum resigns to this, directs sewer lines into the river, and turns it into an open-air main sewer. The facades are brought as close to the river as possible (since a boardwalk isn't happening anyway), stripped to essentials and the cheapest materials, and dotted with sewer pipes and tiny windows for ventilation only. We can also see small jettying that are bathrooms hovering directly over the river. Together, the facades form a unified wall that protects the community from foul smells and unpleasant views. The riverbank is reinforced with concrete to prevent the slum from sliding into the water. A lone person sails the river on a raft, cleaning up floating trash. He is paid many times the average wage but is socially ostracized.
Topo. Slums are forced to reckon with topo (the bottom edge), as they have little means to modify it with manual labor alone (heavy machinery is priced out or simply impossible to use in the slum density). This results in a granular, highly irregular management of topography, creating extreme conditions both good and bad.
Compression. I encountered the narrowest alley on my trip on the topo edge. It was an alley that made me bend over, turn sideways, and remove my backpack to traverse it. Four units faced this narrow portion, with the tops of the door openings cut off by the structure across the alley. The extreme alley nonetheless culminated in a cathartic, spontaneous small observation deck overlooking the slum and the city backdrop. My tour guide had fond childhood memories of this observation deck, where he lounged with his friends.
Alleys. Alleys transition into stairs, following the most optimal path along the topo lines with minimal cut-and-fill. The steps will be irregular in shape and height, morphing into porches and platforms for a variety of uses, such as water storage, recreation areas, business displays, and creating additional entries on multiple levels that allow forgoing ship ladders. The alley façade shifts from entry group one moment to full-height retaining wall the next. The alley frequents T-intersections as it hits a portion of topo too steep to handle and navigates around the obstacle. Alleys also do switchback maneuvers, borrowed from stairs, to hop over obstacles.
Rapids. Water is supplied to slums for 3 hours per day, so for 3 hours every day, every faucet in the slums is opened to fill as many containers with water as possible. Managing water manually causes spills, and in an environment this dense, the spills gather in the alleys and run down the stairs, turning them into rapids. Navigating them is very fun, if a bit precarious.
Daylight. Access to daylight and views is irregular. Fully enclosed alleys one moment become platforms overlooking the whole slum in another. Sometimes, the alleys become luxurious communal balconies. That said, the topo edge, on average, provides more dramatic opportunities for views and daylight than a slum on flat ground.
Ocean. Strangely, slums do not view ocean shores as an asset. Fishing communities set up docks on some parts of the shore, but others treat it as a hostile edge, perhaps because of harsh weather conditions. The facades are unpainted (or the paint has been stripped by the weather); the windows are small and utilitarian, with no decoration aside from kids’ art. The structures are robust, mostly concrete or brick, to resist the winds. In some areas, the rocky shore is treated as a landfill; in others, it's used to set up clothing racks. Since nature, not humans, enforces the hostile edge, kids frequent the area to play when the weather is nice. Some residents bravely set up spice-drying tarps, even though the spice will be gone after just one good gust of wind.
3) URBAN INTRUSION INTO SLUMS
Urban fabric makes plenty of incursions into slums, backed by bottomless finance and fierce enforcers. Intrusions range from positive and mutually beneficial to bordering on crimes against humanity.
Religion. Religion is historically adaptable and flexible. It was always willing to bend a tradition or two if it meant a new parish. In slums, this adaptability is on full display. I’ve seen an orthodox street shrine mirroring Buddhist shrines, a highly unorthodox thing to do. Mosques abandon their traditional shape and keep only the bare functional essence. I often found Christ and Lakshmi sharing the same household shrine. Also, Religion is the most scalable formal entity present. It can be a small shelf shrine, a larger shrine, a full-sized shrine, or a church, and can therefore be present in the deepest corners of the slum, weaving itself into the slum fabric at a fundamental level. No other formal entity matches this quality.
Education. Another formal entity, less integrated than religion but still widely present. Pop-up schools, after-school classes, summer camps, and daycares are ubiquitous and blend seamlessly into the slum fabric. Charities and the private sector run these places (some legally, some not), and their strategy is to go where the need is, rather than compelling the people in need to come to you. Meanwhile, the government takes a more direct approach to education: it levels the slum block and builds a school surrounded by a tall fence. While the open space it provides for play is a unique amenity in the slums, I feel the charities' and private sector's approach is more involved and granular. Also, the slum’s smaller scale limits classroom size, while the government has classes with more than 50 children. With the ideal classroom size being 20-25, you can safely assume half the children are just absorbing vibes.
Utilities. Namely, public restrooms (we’ve covered other utilities previously). Officially, the government treats all slums as temporary. Unofficially, the government has partially resigned itself to them, as shown by government-sponsored public bathrooms. Public restrooms are towering structures in the slums, often the tallest in the area, and always play catch-up to the overwhelming need. They appear ham-fisted, awkwardly airdropped, and barely integrated into slum fabric. Yet their function is critical, even if their primary role is to catch slum residents before they venture into the urban fabric to relieve themselves.
Formalization. Formalization is transforming slum fabric into urban fabric while keeping communities in place or relocating them whole to a nearby location (don’t confuse it with gentrification, when communities are replaced by high earners and dispersed). There are a couple of approaches to formalization, depending on how much they are informed by the slums they are replacing.
Informed. The design intent is to improve people’s lives, so the approach seeks to harvest the existing slum program and put it in a formal container. The slum program will inevitably lose some of its freedom within formal constraints, so the design challenge is to preserve as much of that freedom as possible, get out of the community's way, and practice compassionate, non-egotistical design. The project can take the shape of a high-rise that hosts a slum program on the bottom floors and leaves the upper floors for formal apartments. Another approach is to do infill in the slum, preserving the scale while using formal construction practices. A grid I’ve covered above could also be an example of informed formalization, though it works only in slums that don't yet exist. Each of those examples relinquishes some design control in favor of residents’ self-determination.
Uninformed. The design intent is to substitute a slum with something onlookers would find pretty. The slum is removed, no lessons are learned, and the residents are relocated into a tower with no regard for their needs. The tower engages the remaining slum fabric with a hostile edge - a barbed-wire fence.
Uninformed formalization takes the shape of a human anthill. It’s already covered, so I’ll focus only on the local specifics. The building has the world's slowest elevator with a massive line in front of it. The residents dully ignored my protests and ushered me, a privileged guest, ahead. I still spent ten minutes waiting for it to arrive and another five riding it to the upper floors, as it stopped on every floor. A single elevator, non-ADA, taking a maximum of four people - three, if one of them is me - serving a population of a city block trapped in the sky, as even an average one-bedroom apartment houses six people or more. A round trip to the street can take an hour, as long as a car trip from an American suburb to downtown and back.
Also, the tower replaced a pottery slum and made no attempt to accommodate the community's specialty. As a result, residents continued their pottery business in the newly expanded slum. The building didn’t even offer ground-floor storefronts either; residents had to convert their apartments themselves.
Negligent Formalization. Mahul rehabilitation project demolished the slum and relocated the residents onto unremediated brownfield with toxic air and water. This is design research; we need to stay focused on design, so we’ll assume gross negligence in site selection. The project embraces human anthill status to a T, as it is the densest cluster of high-rises I’ve ever seen in the formal sphere. It has a uniform, dull, oppressive darkness you don’t want to inhabit. The darkness of slums is at least dramatic, contrasting, engaging, cut with frequent beams of light, and human in scale.
Mahul also placed apartments on the ground floor, but went a step further by covering them with a dense web of utility lines, which hindered conversions into businesses. One or two still popped up, but most streets remain bare of activity. Mahul program cleared the streets in the densest place on Earth. This happens in similar, less toxic projects as well. Failing to accommodate Indian entrepreneurial spirit is gross negligence, which is the second one in Mahul.
One project had apartments with no toilets and a paid communal toilet on opposite sides of a busy highway. No comment.
Gentrification. We’ve discussed the mechanism of gentrification in the previous chapters. Mumbai is not immune to it. While in the US the urban fabric always wins, in Mumbai the slums and the urban fabric are in a stalemate, roughly equal in size and with plenty of means and methods to conquer each other’s territory.
On one end, slum communities claim and revitalize the land the urban fabric discarded, integrating it into the formal economy, developing housing and businesses, and living there for decades. So when urban fabric shows up with legal documents, trying to make them move and claim the fruits of their efforts, they aren’t shy about making their voices heard, backed by fists when needed. Smaller and weaker slum communities ward off the urban fabric by individuals threatening to set themselves on fire. This isn't an idle threat; it happened and made developments unmarketable and unsellable. Even good-faith formalization efforts often meet resistance and violence because residents know what those efforts usually look like.
On the other end, we have enterprising individuals from the slums who proactively hunt for areas primed for development, move in, build a rag-tag community in a matter of days, then demand gentrification payouts to move out, squatting for ransom. This doesn’t happen often, as it takes a fair amount of skill and luck to pull off under the nose of an ever-vigilant, powerful, and violent urban fabric.
4) SLUMS INTRUSION INTO URBAN
Sidewalk Communities. Sidewalk communities are something the US population is well familiar with - the homeless tent cities that are violently displaced from one street only to re-appear on the neighboring street. Violence is less effective in India, as the sidewalk residents are numerous, well-organized, and dug in with permanent structures. Because of the linear configuration of the occupied site, sidewalk communities cannot sell their properties to developers or develop into urban fabric themselves. In a way, they are stuck where they are in a tense standoff with urban fabric. Unit prices go up to $100,000 or more, but the value is locked in and can never be turned into cash (like homeowners in the US who are stuck with $1m houses).
Residential one-story. The first surprise is electricity: initially hijacked from the grid, then eventually formalized. Unlike other slums, there is no water line, so the water has to be brought on site in containers. Sidewalk communities are always under pressure, so they rush to create an insulating commercial layer. Residents hang makeshift signs on their dwellings, advertising their trade, trying to gain a foothold in the city. Getting out of your apartment complex and coming face-to-face with a slum is a trivial condition in India, so nobody pays it any mind. Sidewalk communities treat their residences as permanent, decorating and renovating them.
Residential two-story. Sidewalk communities grow up to two stories tall, but no further. While urban fabric can't get rid of the community, it won't let it get out of control either. The boundary is enforced with a fence, barbed wire, spikes, and other hostile architecture. That said, the urban fabric made a concession in the form of a public bathroom, likely to manage waste and make slum/urban fabric co-habitation more tolerable. The residential program gets displaced to the second floor, while the first floor is businesses. A sidewalk means a road is nearby, and a road means customers. As such, the sidewalk community behaves a lot like a road edge, with many businesses such as moped repair shops, cafes, retail, etc. The parking lane next to the sidewalk becomes a porch for business displays, although some avoid the curb and keep their porch on the sidewalk, off the road. I also observed metal trellises built over the façade to hold the tarp, presumably to deal with harsh breezes or prevent moisture infiltration. The one important difference from a road edge is the absence of formal businesses. Because sidewalk communities can't evolve into urban fabric and lack water/sewer utility, formal businesses avoid them and never cross over.
Commercial. Other sidewalk communities evolve into markets (or start as a market from the beginning). The structures are still permanent, but smaller, basic, utilitarian, and less well cared for, since decorations and expensive repairs eat into profit margins. They function more as storage units that open the sectional gate and start trading, extending far from their enclosure onto the sidewalk and road. It begins with moving your main display case out to create more space behind it to sit. From there, ideas start to flow. Mobile partitions covered in merchandise are pushed even farther out as advertising. Merchandise (travel bags) is stacked in towers outside and hung on the roof to be visible from further away. The most proactive merchants put their chairs in front of displays to engage passers-by directly.
All permanent structures respect the curb line, but temporary installations don't, spilling over it and even creating a new curb line with makeshift platforms. This creates a tidal cycle: commerce is neatly contained inside the permanent structures at night, then spills onto the road during the day. Residences are uncommon and likely the result of a failed business, with the owner staying put for the time being (let's note that). Urban fabric is less hostile and pretends it deals with a formal market. Nonetheless, these edges are also harshly enforced with hostile architecture to keep the community contained. Many cabs also park in front of businesses, shuttling clients to and from the train station.
Isolated incursions. Isolated incursions of slums into the urban fabric happen all over Mumbai. The most common example is nomadic merchants who set up their shop at random locations, smack in the middle of the urban fabric, testing the waters. They can pack up and move in a few minutes if asked, and they often are. Such merchants can negotiate a permanent spot with the urban fabric and set up a semi-permanent installation. Commonly, it is a metal box welded or chained to something sturdy, housing the sales paraphernalia that can be quickly unfolded into a point of sale. More exotic examples include permanent modifications of the existing urban fabric. I came across a section of fence decorated with marble tiles and used as an outdoor barbershop: everything was cleared out at the end of the day, but the marble remained to indicate the spot was claimed.
Perhaps the most interesting incursion happened outside of a courthouse. Lawyers and paralegals, sensing a business opportunity, claimed a sidewalk and a colonial fence as an office space. I imagine it was impossible to displace them, since arguing is their job. Conceding defeat, the urban fabric erected a taller, spikier fence to contain the incursion, which the incursion also claimed and set up shading devices. With the foothold firmly established, other merchants popped up, selling snacks, providing printing services, etc. In the end, if you showed up at a courthouse with nothing, you’d get everything you needed in the last fifty feet before the door.
***
With the exterior situation outlined and categorized, let’s explore the interiors before we draw any conclusions.